哈佛计量经济学讲义11
46
$872&255(/$7,21
+GUDIW, 4614###'HILQLWLRQ#RI#$XWRFRUUHODWLRQ
7R#WKLV#SRLQW#LW#KDV#EHHQ#DVVXPHG#WKDW#WKH#YDOXH#WDNHQ#E\#WKH#GLVWXUEDQFH#WHUP/#X L#LQ#DQ\#REVHUYDWLRQ#LV GHWHUPLQHG#LQGHSHQGHQWO\#RI#LWV#YDOXHV#LQ#DOO#WKH#RWKHU#REVHUYDWLRQV1##,Q#RWKHU#ZRUGV/#ZH#KDYH#DVVXPHG WKDW#WKH#WKLUG#*DXVV00DUNRY#FRQGLWLRQ/#WKDW#WKH#SRSXODWLRQ#FRYDULDQFH#RI#X L#DQG#X M#EH#3/#IRU#L#z#M1#LV VDWLVILHG1##+1RWH=##6LQFH#ZH#DUH#DVVXPLQJ#WKDW#(+X L,##(+X M,##3/#WKH#FRQGLWLRQ#PD\#EH#ZULWWHQ#(+X L#X M,# 31,##:KHQ#LW#LV#QRW#VDWLVILHG/#WKH#GLVWXUEDQFH#WHUP#LV#VDLG#WR#EH#VXEMHFW#WR#DXWRFRUUHODWLRQ/#RIWHQ#FDOOHG VHULDO#FRUUHODWLRQ#+WKH#WZR#WHUPV#DUH#LQWHUFKDQJHDEOH,1
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
3RVVLEOH#&DXVHV#RI#$XWRFRUUHODWLRQ
$XWRFRUUHODWLRQ#QRUPDOO\#RFFXUV#RQO\#LQ#UHJUHVVLRQ#DQDO\VLV#XVLQJ#WLPH#VHULHV#GDWD1##7KH#GLVWXUEDQFH WHUP#X#LQ#D#UHJUHVVLRQ#HTXDWLRQ#SLFNV#XS#WKH#LQIOXHQFH#RI#WKRVH#YDULDEOHV#DIIHFWLQJ#WKH#GHSHQGHQW YDULDEOH#WKDW#KDYH#QRW#EHHQ#LQFOXGHG#LQ#WKH#UHJUHVVLRQ#HTXDWLRQ1##,I#WKH#YDOXH#RI#X#LQ#DQ\#REVHUYDWLRQ#LV WR#EH#LQGHSHQGHQW#RI#LWV#YDOXH#LQ#WKH#SUHYLRXV#RQH/#WKH#YDOXH#RI#DQ\#YDULDEOH#KLGGHQ#LQ#X#PXVW#EH XQFRUUHODWHG#ZLWK#LWV#YDOXH#DW#WKH#WLPH#RI#WKH#SUHYLRXV#REVHUYDWLRQ1
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
”#&1#'RXJKHUW\#53331##$OO#ULJKWV#UHVHUYHG1##&RSLHV#PD\#EH#PDGH#IRU#SHUVRQDO#XVH1##9HUVLRQ#RI#5#0DUFK#53331
)LJXUH #46141##3RVLWLYH #DXWRFRUUHODWLRQ
2QH #LPSRUWDQW #SRLQW #WR #QRWH #LV #WKDW #DXWRFRUUHODWLRQ #LV #RQ #WKH #ZKROH #PRUH #OLNHO\#WR #EH #D #SUREOHP #WKH VKRUWHU #WKH #LQWHUYDO #EHWZHHQ #REVHUYDWLRQV 1##2EYLRXVO\/#WKH #ORQJHU #WKH #LQWHUYDO /#WKH #OHVV #OLNHO\#DUH #WKH HIIHFWV #RI #WKH #H[FOXGHG #YDULDEOHV #WR #SHUVLVW #IURP #RQH #REVHUYDWLRQ #WR #WKH #QH[W 1
7KXV #IDU #ZH #KDYH #EHHQ #GLVFXVVLQJ #RQO\#SRVLLYH #DXWRFRUUHODWLRQ 1##,Q #SULQFLSOH #DXWRFRUUHODWLRQ #PD\DOVR #EH #QHJDWLYH 1##7KLV #PHDQV #WKDW #WKH #FRUUHODWLRQ #EHWZHHQ #VXFFHVVLYH #YDOXHV #RI #WKH #GLVWXUEDQFH #WHUP #LV QHJDWLYH 1##$#SRVLWLYH #YDOXH #LQ #RQH #REVHUYDWLRQ #LV #OLNHO\#WR #EH #IROORZHG #E\#D #QHJDWLYH #RQH #LQ #WKH #QH[W /DQG #YLFH #YHUVD /#WKH #VFDWWHU #GLDJUDP #ORRNLQJ #OLNH #)LJXUH #46151
)LJXUH #46151##1HJDWLYH #
DXWRFRUUHODWLRQ
\
\
$JDLQ/#[#LV#DVVXPHG#WR#EH#JURZLQJ#ZLWK#WLPH1##$#OLQH#MRLQLQJ#VXFFHVVLYH#REVHUYDWLRQV#WR#RQH DQRWKHU#ZRXOG#FURVV#WKH#OLQH#UHODWLQJ#\#WR#[#ZLWK#JUHDWHU#IUHTXHQF\#WKDQ#RQH#ZRXOG#H[SHFW#LI#WKH#YDOXHV RI#WKH#GLVWXUEDQFH#WHUP#ZHUH#LQGHSHQGHQW#RI#HDFK#RWKHU1
(FRQRPLF#H[DPSOHV#DUH#UHODWLYHO\#XQFRPPRQ/#EXW#VRPHWLPHV#QHJDWLYH#DXWRFRUUHODWLRQ#LV#LQGXFHG E\#WKH#PDQLSXODWLRQV#XVHG#WR#WUDQVIRUP#WKH#RULJLQDO#VSHFLILFDWLRQ#RI#D#PRGHO#LQWR#D#IRUP#VXLWDEOH#IRU UHJUHVVLRQ#DQDO\VLV1
4615###'HWHFWLRQ#RI#)LUVW02UGHU#$XWRFRUUHODWLRQ=##WKH#'XUELQ0:DWVRQ#7HVW
:H#ZLOO#PRVWO\#EH#FRQFHUQHG#ZLWK#ILUVW0RUGHU#DXWRUHJUHVVLYH#DXWRFRUUHODWLRQ/#RIWHQ#GHQRWHG#$5+4,/ ZKHUH#WKH#GLVWXUEDQFH#WHUP#X#LQ#WKH#PRGHO
\W###D#.#E[W#.#X W+4614,
LV#JHQHUDWHG#E\#WKH#SURFHVV
X W####U X W04#.#H W/+4615,
ZKHUH#H W#LV#D#UDQGRP#YDULDEOH#ZKRVH#YDOXH#LQ#DQ\#REVHUYDWLRQ#LV#LQGHSHQGHQW#RI#LWV#YDOXH#LQ#DOO#WKH RWKHU#REVHUYDWLRQV1##7KLV#W\SH#RI#DXWRFRUUHODWLRQ#LV#GHVFULEHG#DV#DXWRUHJUHVVLYH#EHFDXVH#X W#LV#EHLQJ GHWHUPLQHG#E\#ODJJHG#YDOXHV#RI#LWVHOI#SOXV#WKH#IUHVK#HOHPHQW#RI#UDQGRPQHVV#H W#+H W#LV#VRPHWLPHV GHVFULEHG#DV#DQ#LQQRYDWLRQ,1##,W#LV#GHVFULEHG#DV#ILUVW0RUGHU#EHFDXVH#X W#GHSHQGV#RQO\#RQ#X W04#DQG#WKH LQQRYDWLRQ1##$#SURFHVV#RI#WKH#W\SH
X W##UìX W04#.U?X W05#.UêX W06#.UéX W07#.UèX W08#.#H W/+4616,
ZRXOG#EH#GHVFULEHG#DV#ILIWK0RUGHU#DXWRUHJUHVVLYH#DXWRFRUUHODWLRQ/#GHQRWHG#$5+8,1##7KH#PDLQ#DOWHUQDWLYH WR#DXWRUHJUHVVLYH#DXWRFRUUHODWLRQ#LV#PRYLQJ#DYHUDJH#+0$,#DXWRFRUUHODWLRQ/#ZKHUH#X W#LV#GHWHUPLQHG#DV#D ZHLJKWHG#VXP#RI#FXUUHQW#DQG#SUHYLRXV#YDOXHV#RI#H W1##)RU#H[DPSOH/#WKH#SURFHVV
X W##OíH W#.#OìH W04#.#O?H W05#.#OêH W06+4617,
ZRXOG#EH#GHVFULEHG#DV#0$+6,1
:H#ZLOO#IRFXV#RQ#$5+4,#DXWRFRUUHODWLRQ#EHFDXVH#LW#DSSHDUV#WR#EH#WKH#PRVW#FRPPRQ#W\SH/#DW#OHDVW DV#DQ#DSSUR[LPDWLRQ1##,W#LV#GHVFULEHG#DV#SRVLWLYH#RU#QHJDWLYH#DFFRUGLQJ#WR#WKH#VLJQ#RI#U1##1RWH#WKDW#LI#U#LV 3/#WKHUH#LV#QR#DXWRFRUUHODWLRQ#DIWHU#DOO1
%HFDXVH#$5+4,#LV#VXFK#D#FRPPRQ#IRUP#RI#DXWRFRUUHODWLRQ/#WKH#VWDQGDUG#WHVW#VWDWLVWLF#IRU#LW/#WKH 'XUELQ0:DWVRQ#G/#LV#RIWHQ#LQFOXGHG#LQ#WKH#EDVLF#GLDJQRVWLF#VWDWLVWLFV#SULQWHG#RXW#ZLWK#WKH#UHJUHVVLRQ UHVXOWV1##,W#LV#FDOFXODWHG#IURP#WKH#UHVLGXDOV#XVLQJ#WKH#H[SUHVVLRQ
)LJXUH #46161##'XUELQ 0:DWVRQ #WHVW #IRU #DXWRFRUUHODWLRQ /#VKRZLQJ #WKH #]RQH #RI
LQGHWHUPLQDF\#LQ #WKH #FDVH #RI #VXVSHFWHG #SRVLWLYH #DXWRFRUUHODWLRQ
545
45,+W W W W 7W H H H G e |e| +4618,
,W #FDQ #EH #VKRZQ #+VHH #$SSHQGL[#4615#>QRW #VXSSOLHG@,#WKDW #LQ #ODUJH #VDPSOHV
G #o #5#±#5U ?ìê???
,I #WKHUH #LV #QR #DXWRFRUUHODWLRQ #SUHVHQW /#U #LV #3/#VR #G #VKRXOG #EH #FORVH #WR #51##,I #WKHUH #LV #SRVLWLYH DXWRFRUUHODWLRQ /#G #VKRXOG #WHQG #WR #EH #OHVV #WKDQ #51##,I #WKHUH #LV #QHJDWLYH #DXWRFRUUHODWLRQ /#LW #VKRXOG #WHQG #WR EH #JUHDWHU #WKDQ #51##7KH #WHVW #DVVXPHV #WKDW #U #OLHV #LQ #WKH #LQWHUYDO #±4#!yU y!#4#DQG #KHQFH #WKDW #G #OLHV #EHWZHHQ 7#DQG #31
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
+RZHYHU /#DOO #\RX #NQRZ #LV #G FULW #WKDW #OLHV #VRPHZKHUH #EHWZHHQ #G /#DQG #G 81##7KLV #OHDYHV #\RX #ZLWK #WKUHH SRVVLEOH #RXWFRPHV #IRU #WKH #WHVW 1
57
3G /G 8G
FUL
)LJXUH #46171##'XUELQ 0:DWVRQ #WHVW #IRU #DXWRFRUUHODWLRQ /#VKRZLQJ #WKH #]RQH #RI
LQGHWHUPLQDF\#LQ #WKH #FDVH #RI #VXVSHFWHG #QHJDWLYH #DXWRFRUUHODWLRQ
41
G #LV #OHVV #WKDQ #G /1##,Q #WKLV #FDVH /#LW #PXVW #EH #ORZHU #WKDQ #G FULW /#VR #\RX #ZRXOG #FRQFOXGH #WKDW #SRVLWLYH DXWRFRUUHODWLRQ #LV #SUHVHQW 151
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±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e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o #5#±#5U +4614;, )URP #WKLV #RQH #HVWLPDWHV #U #DV #+40#ò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òG ,# #3147#JLYHV #XV #DQ HVWLPDWH #RI #U 1##7KH #VWDQGDUG #HUURU #RI #WKH #ODJJHG #GHSHQGHQW #YDULDEOH #LV #3137841##7KXV #RXU #HVWLPDWH #RI #WKH YDULDQFH #RI #WKH #FRHIILFLHQW #LV #3133531##7KH #QXPEHU #RI #REVHUYDWLRQV #LV #681##+HQFH #WKH #K #VWDWLVWLF #LV ;913335313684684713 u eu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ì[4W#.#111#.#E N[NW#X W/+46157, WKH#UHVWULFWHG#PRGHO#ZRXOG#KDYH#EHHQ \W###D+40U,#.#U\W04#.#Eì[4W#0#Eì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u eu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òò E D +46164, DQG #ZH #H[HFXWH #D #OLQHDU #UHJUHVVLRQ /#ZH #REWDLQ #WKH #ILW #LOOXVWUDWHG #LQ #)LJXUH #814#DQG #VXPPDUL]HG #LQ #7DEOH 815=##D #QHJDWLYH #UHVLGXDO #LQ #WKH #ILUVW #REVHUYDWLRQ /#SRVLWLYH #UHVLGXDOV #LQ #WKH #QH[W #VL[/#DQG #QHJDWLYH UHVLGXDOV #LQ #WKH #ODVW #WKUHH 1##,Q #RWKHU #ZRUGV /#WKHUH #DSSHDUV #WR #EH #YHU\#VWURQJ #SRVLWLYH #DXWRFRUUHODWLRQ 1+RZHYHU /#ZKHQ #WKH #UHJUHVVLRQ #LV #RI #WKH #IRUP *?E[D \ò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